Impact of biased scores on ranking in bipartite competition networks and inference of modular structure via generalized modularity

Cited 1 time in webofscience Cited 0 time in scopus
  • Hit : 185
  • Download : 0
In the common jury-contestant competition format, a jury consisting of multiple judges grade contestants on their performances to determine their ranking. Unlike in another common competition format where two contestants play a head-to-head match to produce the winner such as in football or basketball, the objectivity of judges are often called into question, potentially undermining the public's trust in the fairness of the competition. In this work we show, by modeling the jury-contestant competition format as a weighted bipartite network, how one can identify biased scores and how they impact the competition and its structure. Analyzing the prestigious International Chopin Piano Competition of 2015 as an example with a well-publicized scoring controversy, we show that the presence of even a very small fraction of biased edges can gravely distort our inference of the network structure-in the example a single biased edge is shown to lead to an incorrect "solution" that also wrongly appears to be robust exclusively, dominating other reasonable solutions- highlighting the importance of bias detection and elimination in network inference. In the process our work also presents a modified modularity measure for the one-mode projection of weighted complete bipartite networks. Copyright (C) EPLA, 2017
Publisher
EPL ASSOCIATION
Issue Date
2017-02
Language
English
Article Type
Article
Keywords

COMPLEX NETWORKS; FOOTBALL-LEAGUE; PATTERNS

Citation

EPL, v.117, no.4

ISSN
0295-5075
DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/117/48005
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/10203/223965
Appears in Collection
GCT-Journal Papers(저널논문)
Files in This Item
There are no files associated with this item.
This item is cited by other documents in WoS
⊙ Detail Information in WoSⓡ Click to see webofscience_button
⊙ Cited 1 items in WoS Click to see citing articles in records_button

qr_code

  • mendeley

    citeulike


rss_1.0 rss_2.0 atom_1.0