Scalable and Secure Virtualization of HSM With ScaleTrust

Abstract

Hardware security modules (HSMs) have been utilized as a trustworthy foundation for cloud services. Unfortunately, existing systems using HSMs fail to meet multi-tenant scalability arising from the emerging trends such as microservices, which utilize frequent cryptographic operations. As an alternative, cloud vendors provide HSMs as a service. However, such cloud-managed HSM usage models raise security concerns due to their untrusted and shared operating environment. We propose ScaleTrust, a scalable and secure system for key management. ScaleTrust allows us to scale the number of virtual HSM partitions, each of which is isolated with respect to each other and is robust against cloud insider attacks, while preserving physical isolation of the root of trust. To enable this, ScaleTrust uses Intel SGX and multiple HSM features, such as restricting key usage by controlling key attributes of in-HSM keys and establishing a secure channel using only HSM commands. Finally, we apply ScaleTrust to four real-world systems: Keyless SSL for TLS private key offloading, JSON Web Token authentication for microservices, key provisioning, and encryption in database systems. Our evaluation shows that ScaleTrust achieves multi-tenancy in a scalable way by providing multiple virtual HSMs with legacy HSM devices that are designed to support a single tenant. ScaleTrust provides security against insider threats while incurring 11.9% and 39.0% of end-to-end throughput and latency overhead for Keyless SSL compared to stand-alone HSMs.